Book Review - Sisterland
Read this on galpod.com.
My incredible reading group read this book in September. I'm telling you this because I don't think I would ever have picked this book up on my own. One of the ladies in the reading group recommended it and said that it spoke to her because she's a twin, so we decided to give it a go.
Generally, it is an interesting book. I mean, I read all 400 pages of Sisterland in about two and a half weeks, so it definitely kept me engaged and interested. I connected with the characters, especially the MC Kate who describes the daily grind of young motherhood in excruciatingly familiar details. Because of this connection I felt with Kate, I kept reading. I wanted to know what happens next, which is I assume what every author aims for.
Four hundred pages. I'm convinced that a good editor would have been invaluable to this work. The back story, in the form of back-flashes, was unnecessary for the most part. It distracted from the story although it did work wonders to describe the relationship between the two sisters. However, I do think the relationship could have been described throughout the story instead of the jarring flash-backs to childhood and college years. The structure of the book didn't work for me, and most people in the reading group agreed. I would have gladly given up much of the backstory in favour of more details at the end of the story, which seemed rushed to me.
Also, I was a little disappointed because I felt that the author touched on several (probably too many) interesting topics but didn't drive the point home. For instance, she describes the daily grind and the loneliness of being a stay-at-home-mother of young children, but she doesn't say anything thoughtful about it. Kate's premonition can be seen as a self-fulfilling prophecy, but there's no reference to that which I think is a shame. And did you notice this is the first time I mentioned a premonition? The premise of the book is that the twins have "senses", but it reads more like a plot device than anything that the author wanted to say something about.
And the ending. I was expecting Kate to come to terms with her gift, but she didn't, which is I guess more original and less cliche. I liked that it was unusual in that way. However, it could be the reason that the ending felt unfinished to me; like we left Kate in the middle of a (much more interesting) story. I think I had this feeling because it doesn't seem like she'd learnt any lessons from her experiences.
So, overall, this book wasn't a favourite. It's a nice read if you like that sort of thing, but I've seen better work.
Hey there! Thanks for reading! If you liked this post, you can subscribe to my blog to get updates and stories straight to your inbox!